For the first time since the Town of Windermere sued 10 of its residents in July 2022, attempting to evict them from the five boathouses in Palmer Park’s lagoon and accusing them of breach of contract, the parties appear close to a settlement, says Town Manager Robert Smith.
If they can ink the deal, it will finally put an end to decades of tugging and warring between town officials and residents over who has rights to the boathouses that dates to the '80s.
While there’s not much to the boathouses — they’re like carports for small watercraft, with a roof and three walls and a fourth side open to the water — they offer coveted access to the Butler Chain of Lakes. A boathouse can also add up to $250,000 in value to a home it’s associated with.

The legal fight here is over a lease agreement between the town and residents originally signed in 1985. The least was extended in 2001, extended again in 2011 and expired in 2021. The residents — some of whom were not signers of the original 1985 lease; some of whom had had a family boathouse for decades — were on month-to-month leases through March 2022 when the town council voted 3-2 to end the leases. Mayor Andy Williams, then a council member, cast the deciding vote.
When the residents banded together, retained legal counsel and refused to vacate, the town filed its lawsuit.
Fast forward to October 2025, and Ninth Circuit Court Judge John Jordan ruled unequivocally that the boathouses were private property belonging to the residents and blasted Windermere for leases that charged residents to access their own property.
In his ruling, Jordan emphasized that the boathouses, built between 1910 and 1915, were constructed before Windermere was incorporated in 1925. And he pointed out that the boathouses had been privately owned through the last 115 years, continually maintained and passed down and sold through owners’ quit claim deeds. He noted that the town had no deeds or titles that showed possession of the structures. And that the leases specifically stated that the structures belong to the boathouse residents.
Jordan wrote in his ruling, that the town has no rights that would allow it to claim possession or determine access.
Even so, the town filed an appeal with the Sixth District Court of Appeal. And later filed a second lawsuit, alleging that “ambiguity” about ownership of the submerged land beneath the boathouses and the grassy swale that’s crossed to access the boathouses, creates a potential safety hazard.

Windermere Town Manager Robert Smith talked with VoxPopuli about where things stand today. Our conversation has been lightly edited for clarity.
VoxPopuli: What can you tell me about the settlement?
Robert Smith: All I can say is that we're very, very close. You know, we're just negotiating over a couple of words, but I believe that we'll have a settlement that I can bring to town council.
VoxPopuli: Would the settlement put the appeal and the second lawsuit to rest?
Robert Smith: It would resolve all.
VoxPopuli: Can you address the escalating legal expenses for this lawsuit, which are now approaching $1 million?
Robert Smith: Litigation is never cheap. The council had a position at the very beginning, and then going through the court system, I understand that they knew it was not gonna be something that was not gonna cost money, especially with an appeal. But I would say we're close to a settlement.
VoxPopuli: After the initial October ruling, the boathouse owners’ attorney said that he would immediately file for attorneys’ fees, which are substantial. When we last checked, they were $800,000 and it’s almost certainly more now. So would that settlement include attorneys fees for the boathouse owners?
Robert Smith: I can't get into the terms of the settlement because that has not been presented to town council yet. But both parties have reviewed it, and both parties — meaning me and the liaison that’s been negotiating this — feel comfortable. So it'll be brought to council at a shade meeting and then taken to a council meeting subsequent to that.
VoxPopuli: Why was the original October Ninth Circuit Court decision appealed?
Robert Smith: I think it was just trying to get their day in court and present their evidence, which I don't think the evidence was accepted or presented at those hearings. What Judge Jordan's summary judgment presented still didn't give any answers to any of the questions that I think both parties were asking for. Who owns what? And so the appeal was submitted to be like, Okay, we need to know who owns what Or Who's entitled to what? And that summary judgment did not state that. It was saying, Hey, you don't own it. And then plaintiff, You don't own it. You know, this is something for somebody else to determine, and that was not the crux of the case. The crux of the case was to figure out who owns what So the intent of the appeal was pure. It was, Okay, well, we didn't get what we were looking for and we still have this outstanding issue that we need to get through. So I believe that's why the appeal was submitted.
VoxPopuli: So Judge Jordan's ruling did not say that the boathouses belong to the boathouse owners?
Robert Smith: It did not. It said the lease was invalid and did not give specificity of who owns what.
[Editor’s Note: Judge Jordan’s order denying the town’s motion on summary judgment for eviction and breach of contract stated that the original 1985 lease was invalid, but it also stated that the town had no legal claim on the boathouses or the land under them: “The Town has not been deeded any interest in the privately owned Lagoon area where the boathouses are situated, and it does not hold title or ownership rights in the private submerged lands underneath the five boathouses. Therefore, the Town has no ownership claim to the boathouse structures or the land underneath them which could support a claim of possession to the boathouse structures at issue in this case.]
VoxPopuli: Why did the town want the boathouses? They're really not that attractive.
Robert Smith: No, they're not attractive. I mean, there was really just trying to clarify because this was litigated in the eighties. And it probably should have gone all the way through instead of entering into leases as a settlement. It was always trying to figure out who owns what, who's entitled to what. We got some of those answers through litigation, you know, which assists us in trying to reach a settlement.
VoxPopuli: If the town had acquired the boathouses, what was the plan for them?
Robert Smith: There was a lot of discussions, but the ultimate recommendation was to keep them as static historical structures. Like museum pieces. That was discussed at one of the workshops. But nothing definitive was stated because we had to get through any and all litigation first to determine who owns what. There were conversations about a lottery system for using them. But again, nothing was definitively done. It was just conversations about, Well, what would you like to do with these?
VoxPopuli: Did the potential and now the reality of Amendment 3 influence the push for a settlement? Kind of spur this along, like we’ve got bigger fish to fry, sort of thing?
Robert Smith: The conversations have been going on, I think probably from the first year of litigation up until this point. It was just coming up with something that would be fair and equitable. So it took a lot of time, but I think we're very, very close. And I think presenting it to council as a whole during a shade meeting and then a public meeting, I think that's gonna be very beneficial.
VoxPopuli: But did Amendment 3 factor into this at all? Because all municipalities are going to be pressed for funds, but $1 million on legal —
Robert Smith: No, it did not. The intent was always to try to work something out during the entire litigation portion. I think we’re close. We were close probably a month ago. And we’re still working on the nuances of the agreement. But Amendment 3 did not have an impact on this.
VoxPopuli: Was this good stewardship of taxpayer dollars to fight this fight over these boathouses? Was this money well spent?
Robert Smith: I mean the town is called "Among the Lakes." So the town really doesn't have that many places where the public can enjoy the lakes. So the intent, again, was to figure out what the legal rights were for that area so we can determine what to do with it and, you know, what would be the highest and best use for the land. So that's, that's my statement on that.
VoxPopuli: This was an emotional issue for the town. People resigned from committees and boards they served on. Harsh words were said on both sides. Windermere is such a close-knit community. Is there a way to heal after this?
Robert Smith: You have people on both sides. I think the vocal minority were saying the same thing or telling us, Hey you know I think this is something we should look into just to get final determination. A lot of the negative feedback we got were from the litigants, their neighbors, their friends. But I mean, we're not looking to admonish or to punish anybody. Our whole goal was to try to get answers to questions that should have been dealt with in '85, '86. Litigation, it seems adversarial, but we never approached it that way. We approached it that we were looking for answers, let's find out the answers and go from there. But again, litigation's never fun.